H
  
Contact Us   
Scottish  ::  Bookish  ::  Gallas  

 Gallus or Mince?

"What good are insights? They only make things worse." Raymond Carver

:: February 2007

I Feel Bad about my Neck (Nora Ephron, 2006)

"People have only one way to be. Buy, don’t rent. Never marry a man you wouldn’t want to be divorced from. Don’t cover a couch with anything that isn’t more or less beige. Don’t buy anything that is 100 percent wool even if it seems to be very soft and not particularly itchy when you try it on in the store. You can’t be friends with people who call after 11 p.m. The world’s greatest babysitter burns out after two and a half years. The empty nest is underrated. If the shoe doesn’t fit in the shoe store, it’s never going to fit. When your children are teenagers, it’s important to have a dog so that someone in the house is happy to see you. Back up your files. Over insure everything. There’s no point in making piecrust from scratch. If friends ask you to be their child’s guardian in case they die in a plane crash, you can say no."

Comments: Ephron is the screenwriter for such romantic comedies as Sleepless in Seattle and You’ve Got Mail. She has also been carving out a niche for herself as angst-chronicler for women of a certain age. Yes, she is witty, and yes, she is smart, and yes, this book is more melancholy than one expects. Yet do I do I sympathize with her when she tells me she spends the equivalent of small country's GDP on her beauty upkeep per month? Probably not. But should I hate her just ‘cause she’s rich, as well as smart and funny? You decide.

:: July 2006

An Inconvenient Truth (Al Gore, 2006)

"Number of peer reviewed articles dealing with climate change published in scientific journals during the last ten years: 928. Percentage of articles in doubt as to the cause of global warming: 0%. Number of articles in the popular press about global warming in the last fourteen years: 636. Percentage of articles in doubt as to the cause of global warming: 53%."

Comments: Al Gore (once called 'Ozone-Man' by George Bush Senior) has reinvented himself as the new Jimmy Carter, a man who can get more done out of public office than in it. So will the world's best selling powerpoint presentation manage to finally wake up dozy mankind, and an even dozier White House? I hope so.

Verdict: Scary-Swoty-Gallus

:: May 2006

Marley and Me: Life and Love with the World's Worst Dog (John Grogan, 2005)

"The heartwarming and unforgettable story of a family in the making and the wondrously neurotic dog that taught them what really matters in life."

Comments: Hey, it's one of those books with the colon in the title....and the quote from the book jacket above is making me feel a little nauseous. I've the feeling this is going to be a stinker, albeit a weepy stinker...

Verdict: Schmaltzy-Mince

:: November

Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince ( J. K. Rowling, 2005)

" “To the Prime Minister of Muggles. Urgent we meet. Kindly respond immediately. Sincerely, Fudge.”

The man in the painting looked inquiringly at the Prime Minister. “Er,” said the Prime Minister, “listen... Its not a very good time for me ... I’m waiting for a telephone call, you see... from the President of —”

“That can be rearranged,” said the portrait at once. The Prime Minister’s heart sank. He had been afraid of that.

“But I really was rather hoping to speak —”

“We shall arrange for the President to forget to call. He will telephone tomorrow night instead,” said the little man. “Kindly respond immediately to Mr. Fudge.”

“I... oh ... very well,” said the Prime Minister weakly. “Yes, I’ll see Fudge.”

He hurried back to his desk, straightening his tie as he went. He had barely resumed his seat, and arranged his face into what he hoped was a relaxed and unfazed expression, when bright green flames burst into life in the empty grate beneath his marble mantelpiece. He watched, trying not to betray a flicker of surprise or alarm, as a portly man appeared within the flames, spinning as fast as a top. Seconds later, he had climbed out onto a rather fine antique rug, brushing ash from the sleeves of his long pin-striped cloak, a lime-green bowler hat in his hand.

“Ah... Prime Minister,” said Cornelius Fudge, striding forward with his hand outstretched. "Good to see you again."

Comments: It's time to talk about HP. I know there are many Clanners out there (and Clannish offspring) who have much to say in the defence of the latest Wizarding installment. So, calling all Muggles!. Was it gallus, or was it mince?

VERDICT: Super-Galla-Frastic

 

:: October

The Kite Runner ( Khaled Hosseini, 2003)

"In Kabul, fighting kites was a little like going to war. As with any war, you had to ready yourself for battle..."

Comments: Hosseini's first novel has been on the best seller list in the US for well over a year. It has done equally well in Canada, but not so well in the UK. Is it, as some critics claim, heartbreaking, powerful and moving? Or is it, as others have contended, over-sentimentalized and over-popular due to its timely setting in Afghanistan? Is it magic? Or is it mince?

VERDICT: Gallus-Worthy

 

:: September

The Da Vinci Code (Dan Brown, 2004)

"Mr Langdon," the message began in a fearful whisper. "Do not react to this message. Just listen calmly. You are in danger right now. Follow my directions very closely."

Clan Comments: The Thane was particularly struck by the fact that the word 'message' turned up twice in the above quote - rather indicative of Mr. Brown's enthusiasm for plot over prose. It's also pleasing to read a book that shares her mistrust of anyone who drives an Audi (darned foreign cars) or is born an Albino. And it was about time someone mentioned that some of the 'boys' in Leo's daubs are funny looking. Clan-Lass Jill said that "the identity of the good guys is obvious; the identity of the bad guys is pretty obvious and I still couldn't put it down because I had to be sure." Clan-Lad David agreed with her. He read it on a cross-Canada flight. "A couple of chapters later I had to rest my eyes, bad idea not to blink on a plane at altitude," though he did admit that "the prose stinks." Clanetta Dee expressed concern over our gall at even having the 'gallus or mince' debate. "How can we possibly hang a book that everyone is reading?" she asked. My dearest D. you're dealing with Scots here - we not only hang, we draw and quarter, (and if truth be told, behead, bespear, bepike and do unbespeakable things to sheep). We did it to royalty, we did it to peasants, given the chance we'd do it to politicians and realtors - so a mangy wee paperback doesnay tickle this thane's conscience....
VERDICT: Gallus Mince : Totally gripping nonsense. (Late verdict in from the Laird: "it was shite..." )
About Us | Blog | Contact Us | Editor | ©2005 BookClan
Web site design solutions by E-Global